Joyner’s Canadian Art Auction, 1st Session

May 27, 2008


Lot 50A


Lot 50A Details


oil on composite wood-pulp board
with the estate stamp recto and verso, a faint pencil inscription “TT 62” on the reverse
8 1/2 ins x 10 1/2 ins; 21.3 cms x 26.3 cms

Estimate $800,000-$1,200,000

Realised: $1,207,500
Price Includes Buyer's Premium ?

Lot Report

Additional Images

Estate of the artist
Elizabeth Thomson Harkness (sister of the artist), Annan and Owen Sound, Ontario
Mellors Galleries (later Laing Fine Art Galleries), Toronto
Mrs. George Dunbar, Toronto (acquired circa 1940)
Dr. George David Garland (her nephew), Toronto
By descent to the present owner


Charles C. Hill and Dennis Reid, Tom Thomson, Art Gallery of Ontario and National Gallery of Canada, Toronto and Ottawa, 2002, pages 137-139 for an account of the sketches of 1916 and pages 266-273, plates 111-118 for related works painted during the fall of 1916.


Dr. George D. Garland, O.C. (1926-2008) was born in Toronto and was a Professor of Physics at the University of Toronto. In 1984 he was appointed to the Order of Canada for his research in geophysics. The year book, Torontoensis, mentions Dr. Garland’s love of being out in the bush. According to his daughter, Dr. Garland built his first cabin when he was in his early 20’s. His cottage on Smoke Lake in Algonquin Park remains in the family. In 1989, The Friends of Algonquin Park published a book entitled Glimpses of Algonquin: Thirty Personal Impressions From Earliest Times To The Present which was compiled by Dr. Garland. A memorial service celebrating Dr. Garland’s life will be held by The Friends of Algonquin Park in June, 2008.

This painting will be included in Joan Murray’s forthcoming catalogue raisonne of the artist’s work.

According to Joan Murray:

“Although Tom Thomson was raised on a farm in the Georgian Bay area of Ontario, at Leith, eleven kilometers from Owen Sound, it was not until after he painted on Canoe Lake in Algonquin Park in 1912 that he truly came to appreciate the northern landscape. With its low rolling hills, rippling waters, and excellent fishing opportunities (so congenial to a man who loved fishing like Thomson), the area attracted many because it offered a fascinating and novel terrain.

View from a Height, Algonquin Park was painted in the fall of 1916. In late May of that year, Thomson had taken a job as a fire ranger, following the Booth Lumber Company’s drives down the Petawawa River at the north end of the Park. He was stationed at Achray on Grand Lake and in August, with his friend Ed Godin, took a canoe trip down the south branch of the Petawawa (now the Barron) River and up the north branch of Lake Traverse. He probably returned to Toronto in late October or early November. The hints at fall colouring in this sketch and its view from a height suggest that he may have painted it when he was at Achray or on his canoe trip.

Thomson’s sketches of 1916 are characterized by formal invention and elegant colouration. This sketch, likely painted at twilight, explores a theme of trees against water and distant hills, one which recalls in essence his sketches for The West Wind and The Jack Pine, though here the view is taken from a height. The work is unusual since he painted it on a wood-pulp board by contrast to most of the season’s sketches which were on wood panel. Here, as in other sketches of 1916, he used subtly contrasting colours, low in tone, and handled the paint with great fluidity. This compact painting with its strong design and sense of mystery exudes a powerful and compelling visual poetry.”

We thank Joan Murray for her contribution to the cataloguing of this lot.


For condition information please contact the specialist.


About Condition Ratings

  • 5 Stars: Excellent - No discernable damage, flaws or imperfections
  • 4 Stars: Very Good - Minor flaws or imperfections visible only under close inspection using specialised instruments or black light
  • 3 Stars: Good - Minor flaws visible upon inspection under standard lighting
  • 2 Stars: Fair - Exhibits flaws or damage that may draw the eye under standard lighting
  • 1 Star: Poor - Flaws or damage immediately apparent under standard lighting (examples: missing components, rips, broken glass, damaged surfaces, etc.)

Note: Condition ratings and condition details are the subjective opinions of our specialists and should be used as a guide only. Waddington’s uses due care when preparing condition details, however, our staff are not professional restorers or conservators. Condition details and reports are not warranties and each lot is sold “as is” in accordance with the buyer’s terms and conditions of sale. In all cases the prospective purchaser is responsible for inspecting the property themselves prior to placing a bid.